Investigated reportLogged and followed up by an investigating group.On the recordIn a newspaper, police, government or court record, or from a named public witness.Told storyFolklore, oral tradition or a story passed along.Proven hoaxProven or confessed hoax.
Can you visit?LabelType
1North Shore Monster of the Great Salt Lake On the record
Water monster · Monument Point, north shore of the Great Salt Lake, Box Elder County · first reported 1877 · also called Old Briney
The Great Salt Lake is too salty for fish, yet it has a monster story. In 1877, J.H. McNeil and other workers at the Barnes and Co. salt works near Monument Point told Utah newspapers that a huge animal came out of the lake at night. They described a crocodile-like body and a head like a horse, and some put its length at about 75 feet. They said it bellowed, came toward the shore and sent the men running into the hills. Later writers suggested it might have been a bison wading in the shallows. An even older tale has a Brother Bainbridge seeing a dolphin-like creature off Antelope Island around 1847. The Deseret News has retold these 'briny' legends for generations.
1877On the record Salt works crew led by J.H. McNeil said a crocodile-bodied, horse-headed beast bellowed and charged them from the water at night; they fled up the hills. Source: deseret.com
c. 1847Told story A Brother Bainbridge is said to have seen a monster with a dolphin-like body in the water near Antelope Island. Source: deseret.com
Open to visit
Visiting: Antelope Island State Park offers public access to the lake.
Water monster · Moon Lake, Duchesne County, Ashley National Forest · first reported 1994 · also called Moonie
Moon Lake sits high on the south slope of the Uinta Mountains, and the local resort has kept alive the story of 'Moonie.' The best-known account comes from former resort owner Bill Reardon, who described seeing a ripple zigzag across the calm lake at dawn in 1994, as if something big were moving just under the surface. Others tell of a dark shape below the water and a V-shaped wake with no boat in sight. The legend blends lake-monster sightings with older water-spirit and drowned-child stories told in the region. Skeptics would point to large trout, otters, wind or boat wakes on a cold mountain lake.
1994Told story Bill Reardon, then running the Moon Lake Resort, said he saw a ripple zigzagging across glassy water at daybreak. His account was published in 1998. Source: folkbestiary.com
Tours, museum or events
Visiting: Moon Lake Resort and Forest Service campground.
Water monster · Utah Lake, Utah County · first reported traditional · also called water babies
Across the Great Basin, Native peoples tell of water babies: small, dangerous water beings that live in lakes and springs. In Ute tradition they are linked to Utah Lake. People say their crying can be heard from the water at night or when the lake is still, sounding like an infant, and that the sound is a warning to stay away from certain parts of the shore. These stories belong to living tribal traditions, and much of their meaning is not public. What is shared serves as guidance about respecting dangerous water. This entry keeps to the outline found in public sources.
Other · Near Fort Duchesne, Uintah County · first reported 1996 · also called Sherman Ranch, UFO ranch
Skinwalker Ranch is a 480-acre property in the Uinta Basin next to the Uintah and Ouray Reservation. In 1996 the Sherman family, who had run cattle there, told the Deseret News of strange lights, UFOs, voices, crop-circle-like marks and mutilated cattle. Las Vegas businessman Robert Bigelow bought the ranch that year, and his National Institute for Discovery Science studied it from 1997 until the group disbanded in 2004. Researchers reported odd events, including a calf found emptied and bloodless 45 minutes after tagging, but struggled to produce publishable evidence. Brandon Fugal bought the ranch in 2016, and it became a History Channel series. The name borrows a Diné concept; see the Skinwalker dossier for that tradition.
1996On the record Terry and Gwen Sherman described lights, unexplained cattle deaths and other events on their ranch to the Deseret News. Source: folkbestiary.com
late 1990sInvestigated report NIDS investigators recorded a tagged 84-pound calf found dead with an empty body cavity and no blood within 45 minutes. They ruled out several explanations but published no firm conclusion. Source: deseret.com
Beast · Dead Horse Point, near Moab, San Juan County · first reported traditional
Dead Horse Point is a narrow mesa high above the Colorado River, connected to the plateau by a thin neck of land. The legend says horses were once left behind on the point and, stranded above a river they could see but not reach, died of thirst. Visitors say a pale ghost horse sometimes appears at dusk against the red cliffs. It is a story about loss rather than a monster, but it is one of the best-known spooky tales of canyon country.
Open to visit
Visiting: Dead Horse Point State Park, off UT-313 near Moab.
Water monster · Bear Lake, Rich County (Utah-Idaho line) · first reported 1860s
Utah's most famous lake monster, a serpent with a horse-like head first popularized in the Deseret News in the 1860s. See the main Bear Lake Monster dossier.