Investigated reportLogged and followed up by an investigating group.On the recordIn a newspaper, police, government or court record, or from a named public witness.Told storyFolklore, oral tradition or a story passed along.Proven hoaxProven or confessed hoax.
Can you visit?LabelType
1Glocester Ghoul On the record
Beast · Paige Farm area, Glocester, Providence County · first reported 1830s (printed 1889) · also called Glocester Monster
The Glocester Ghoul comes from a treasure hunt gone wrong. As retold in an 1889 Providence Journal piece, a group of men digging for buried treasure on a Glocester farm in the 1830s said a monstrous animal rose up and drove them off. The description is a nightmare collage: eyes as big as pewter bowls, bat-like wings, ram's horns, duck-like feet and scales the size of clam shells. One of the diggers was said to be Albert Hicks, who later became infamous as a pirate and was hanged in 1860. A second account from 1896 described an elephant-sized beast. Folklorists read it as a classic treasure-guardian tale, the kind meant to explain why the digging came up empty.
1830s (date given as 1833 or 1839)Told story Treasure diggers including a man named Albert Hicks said a huge winged, horned, scaled creature chased them from the site. Source: preston-posits.com
May 5, 1889On the record The Providence Journal printed the story of the treasure hunt and the creature. Source: preston-posits.com
January 15, 1896Told story A later account attributed to Neil Hopkins described a beast as big as an elephant, without a tail, that made a metallic sound. Source: preston-posits.com
Water monster · Off Block Island · first reported June 27, 1996
In June 1996, the crew of a fishing boat named the Mad Monk pulled up a strange carcass off Block Island. Accounts describe a skeleton roughly fourteen feet long, with no fins, a spear-shaped skull and fleshy whiskers. The local press called it the Block Ness Monster. A biologist examined it, and the leading explanation was the rotting remains of a basking shark, whose carcasses are famous for turning into fake sea serpents as they decay. The remains were later reported stolen from a freezer, ending any chance of more testing. Another odd carcass was reported on the island in 2004.
June 27, 1996On the record The Mad Monk's crew brought in a long, finless, serpent-like carcass. A biologist, named as Lee Scott, examined it, and a basking shark was the favored identification. Source: preston-posits.com
2004Told story A second mysterious carcass was reported on Block Island. Source: petakovmedia.com
Open to visit
Visiting: Block Island is reached by ferry from Point Judith; the beaches are public.
Water monster · Teddy's Beach, Portsmouth (Island Park) · first reported 2002
A small beach on the Sakonnet River in Portsmouth produced one of New England's odder modern sea monster stories. A couple from Fall River and a fishing friend told a Providence TV news crew that a creature about fifteen feet long, with a round head, sharp teeth and pale underside, came at them in the shallows. They said it hissed, brushed against the woman's leg and spat water, and the friend showed a leg wound. Commentators suggested a wolf eel or another large eel-like fish. The story lives on mostly through the TV clip and online discussion, and no animal was ever caught.
2002On the record Rachel Carney and Dennis Vasconcellos, with fishing friend Joey Mailloux, described the creature on Channel 12 news. Mailloux had a wound on his leg. Source: preston-posits.com
Ape-like · Great Swamp (South Kingstown), Foster, Exeter and the Blackstone Valley · first reported 1998 · also called Rhode Island Bigfoot
Rhode Island is small and crowded, but people still report Bigfoot-like figures in its wooded western towns and in the Great Swamp. Enthusiasts call it Big Rhodey. Reports describe an upright, ape-like figure six to eight feet tall, white or brown, with a sloping forehead. They include a cyclist near Glendale in 1998, a hiker in the Great Swamp in 2006, and a driver on Route 6 in Foster in 2010. Some of these are drawn from a national Bigfoot research database. Skeptics point out that black bears have been spreading back into Rhode Island and that the state's forests are thin and close to roads.
October 15, 1998Told story A cyclist with a large dog reported a tall upright figure near Glendale in the Blackstone Valley. Source: preston-posits.com
April 15, 2010Told story A motorist reported a tall, ape-like figure along Route 6 in Foster. Source: preston-posits.com
Open to visit
Visiting: Great Swamp Management Area in West Kingston is public land.
Other · Chestnut Hill Baptist Church Cemetery, Exeter · first reported 1892 · also called Mercy Brown vampire incident
Mercy Brown is not a cryptid, but she is Rhode Island's most famous monster story, and it really happened. Tuberculosis killed several members of the Brown family of Exeter over a decade. When 19-year-old Mercy died in January 1892 and her brother Edwin was gravely ill, neighbors feared a dead relative was feeding on the living. On March 17, 1892, the family graves were opened. Mercy's body, kept through a cold winter, looked fresher than the others, and blood was found in her heart. Her heart and liver were burned and the ashes given to Edwin in a drink. He died two months later. Historians call it one of the last New England vampire panics.
March 17, 1892On the record Villagers and a doctor exhumed the Brown family dead. Mercy's heart and liver were burned and mixed into a tonic for her brother Edwin, who died about two months later. Source: en.wikipedia.org
Open to visit
Visiting: Mercy Brown's grave is in the cemetery behind Chestnut Hill Baptist Church in Exeter; visit respectfully.
Lights · Sandy Point, Block Island · first reported 1738 wreck; light reported by 1810 · also called Palatine ghost ship
In December 1738, the ship Princess Augusta, carrying German Palatine emigrants, ran aground at Sandy Point on Block Island after a terrible voyage that had already killed most of its passengers. Out of that tragedy grew a legend of a burning phantom ship seen off the island around the holidays, often tied to a woman passenger who would not leave the wreck. A doctor named Aaron Willey wrote in 1811 about a light he saw on the water near the island, sometimes small and sometimes as big as a ship. John Greenleaf Whittier's 1867 poem The Palatine made the story famous. No remains of the wreck have been found.
December 27, 1738On the record The Princess Augusta wrecked at Sandy Point in a snowstorm. Islanders rescued surviving passengers the next day. Source: en.wikipedia.org
February 1810On the record Dr. Aaron C. Willey described a fire-like light on the water near Block Island in a letter to Dr. Samuel Mitchill. Source: preston-posits.com
Open to visit
Visiting: Sandy Point and North Light on Block Island are public.